Traackr
Day 29 after signup
Organic advocacy fell to 53%. Now it's climbing back
What we're watching, plus a live playbook on Nov 17
Why it works
- Open with a timely point of view, then support it with specific benchmark figures and examples.
- Organize the main ideas into clear sections so readers can move from insights to a relevant event and product resource.
How it is built
- Personal opening
- Past webinar takeaways
- New benchmark insights
- Live event invitation
Email copy
Around this time last year, I said something on a webinar that I still think about: the brands that win the holidays don't start in Q4. They start with the creators who were already talking about them all year. A year later, I want to push that further. Knowing advocacy matters is the easy part. Finding it in your own data, and keeping it growing while paid takes up more of your program, is where most teams get stuck. So this month, I'm sharing what we learned last year, what's changed since, and where to see it all come together live on November 17th with Dolce & Gabbana and Laboratoires Pierre Fabre. Looking back on what we said last year Last December, Pattern Beauty's former CMO, Tiffani Carter, and Innisfree's Caroline Hyche joined me to talk about carrying holiday momentum into the new year. Three ideas from that session still hold up. Peaks amplify the advocacy you already have. Eight of the top 10 beauty brands from Q1 to Q3 2024 also led the holiday season. They didn't break out in Q4. They had been building creator buzz all year. Retain before you recruit. We suggested a simple benchmark: retain at least 40% of your best creators from peak season. And "best" meant your strongest advocates, judged by how often they mention you and how well their audience fits, alongside views. Advocacy shows up before and after the paid moment. Tiffani told us Pattern reviews creator retention every quarter in Traackr, looking at how many creators talk about the brand organically before and after a paid partnership. Caroline described Innisfree tracking every creator who mentions the brand and moving them from the seeding list toward long-term paid partnerships. What's changed since Organic's share shrank, then started coming back. In Traackr's Worldwide Beauty benchmark, organic content's share of creator performance fell from 84% in 2022 to 53% in 2025. Organic attention itself still grew 51% over that stretch. Paid amplification simply grew faster. Early 2026 data shows organic share climbing back to 59%, with brands such as L'Oréal Paris, Smirnoff, and Vaseline seeing the biggest shift. Returning creators carried the holidays. In our 2026 State of Holiday Season Report, top brands earned 57% of their holiday attention from creators they'd already worked with earlier in the year, compared with 51% for everyone else. In Beauty, that gap was 70% vs. 52%. The 2027 question is how to grow both. Paid isn't going anywhere, and it shouldn't. The brands pulling ahead are building an organic base that paid can amplify. “How do I find the creators already advocating for my brand?” That's exactly what we're unpacking live with two influencer marketing leaders: Piera Valentina Toniolo, Global Head of Influencer Marketing at Dolce & Gabbana, and Elena Suarez-Peña, Director, Influencer, PR & Corporate Communications at Laboratoires Pierre Fabre. Join me on Tuesday, November 17th at 12pm ET where we'll cover: How to spot the creators already advocating for your brand, and which ones are worth a longer relationship What a seeding program built for lasting advocacy looks like, from who gets product to what happens after it lands How advocacy plays out differently across categories Where to invest in 2027 so organic grows alongside paid Plus rapid-fire 2027 predictions from both panelists and a live Q&A. Save your spot New | The Luxury Creator Index Luxury is one of the most interesting places to watch advocacy. So we built a way to watch it. The Luxury Creator Index ranks 75 luxury houses across 16 markets by Brand Vitality Score, updated every quarter. You can follow any maison's creator attention month by month, compare two side by side, and click into a spike to see which creators drove it. It also breaks each house's score into the same four levers we use for every brand. Two of them are advocacy signals: creator volume (how many unique creators talk about you) and content frequency (how often they come back). Whatev