Fulcrum
Day 20 after signup
this won’t pay your bills
(it’s not 2016 anymore)
Why it works
- Open with a timely invitation, then use a clear audience problem to make the event feel relevant.
- Build the case with a contrast between rented social reach and an owned email list before presenting the offer.
- Make the event concrete with a day-by-day agenda, then close with a clear deadline and signup action.
How it is built
- Personal opening
- Social proof invitation
- Email list argument
- Sprint agenda
Email copy
Hey there—it’s Cole. Before we dive in: Are you joining us for our upcoming Start & Scale Your Newsletter Sprint? 471 others have already said they'll be there. Click here to save your free spot. Now, a question for you: How many followers do you think you need before you start a newsletter (and use it to make money)? 1,000? 10,000? 100,000? Well, I have over 250,000 followers on X. And most of my posts reach less than 1% of them. Yep, you read that right. LESS THAN 1%!!! And if I promoted a product in those posts, only a small fraction would actually buy because I have ZERO control over who reads my content—every post goes to a different slice of people, some who don’t even know me. Which tells you everything you need to know about what you should be prioritizing to make money online in 2026: Followers alone don't pay the bills. But do you know who does? Email list subscribers. Now, I've been writing online since 2007, and I've watched the internet change a lot. Back in the early 2010s, if you had 10,000 followers and you made a post, a big chunk of those followers actually saw it. That was the whole point of building an audience: More followers = more reach = more cash. But around 2016, everything changed. Social platforms stopped showing you posts from the people you follow… and started showing you posts about the topics you're interested in. Which means the algorithm decides who sees your writing—not you. But so many people still hold the faulty belief that followers = instant cash. I know tons of creators who have huge audiences but are failing to monetize them. So, what’s the solution? Easy: Building an email list. Because every email you send is a direct communication to a group of people who have already raised their hands and said they want to hear more from you. Whereas if you try to get sales from social media, you’re at the mercy of the platforms. Remember, every post hits a different slice of people, so you can never count on your potential buyers seeing your offer. No bueno. So, does that mean social media is pointless? Not at all. It just means social media isn't where you KEEP an audience anymore. It's for FINDING one—and then moving it somewhere you own and control (hint: your email list!). Because platforms now show posts by topic, someone with zero followers can reach the right readers from day one. You don’t need a big audience to get subscribers—you just need to be crystal clear on your niche and who you want to reach. So the whole point of posting online really comes down to 2 things: Building a library of helpful content in your niche (so the right people can discover you). Moving those readers onto your email list (so you can reach them whenever you want—no algorithm standing in your way). And just to drive this point home: 99% of the sales I’ve made as a writer over the last 15+ years have come from an email list—not social media. So, to go back to our original question: “How many followers do you think you need before you start a newsletter (and use it to make money)?” Is actually the WRONG question to be asking. Because you don't need an audience to start a newsletter. Instead, you start a newsletter to build one. Because here’s the thing: Followers are a lagging indicator. You don't get followers and THEN start writing valuable content. You write valuable content in a niche—and THEN people follow (and subscribe). Why? Because they want to hear more (and potentially buy) from you. Which means you need to be seen as an authority in your niche—and the fastest way to build that is by writing longer, deeper pieces about your topic. And what’s the best way to do this? Yup, you guessed it: WITH A NEWSLETTER! Because every time you write an issue, you have 10+ pieces of social content—content you can use to drive attention to your newsletter and ultimately build an audience you own and can market & sell to. And that's what actually pays the bills.