Food52
Day 46 after signup
The pies we're making for Thanksgiving.
Plus, essential tips for the best pie crust.
Why it works
- Open with a timely hosting challenge, then frame the topic around a useful benefit such as getting dessert ready ahead of time.
- Organize a broad editorial issue into distinct sections so readers can browse recipes, product ideas, and practical advice.
- Pair inspiration with specific, actionable tips to make the newsletter useful beyond the featured recommendations.
How it is built
- Issue label
- Seasonal introduction
- Recipe recommendations
- Serving product suggestions
Email copy
ISSUE 19 If you're in charge of dessert this Thanksgiving (arguably one of the most important responsibilities) and are feeling the pressure to make something memorable, we have a few ideas. We love pie for its contrast of textures: buttery, flaky crust; creamy or jammy fillings; and, of course, a dollop of fresh whipped cream. It's also a great make-ahead dessert, allowing you to cross at least one thing off your list the day before. You can even freeze your pie crust now. Thanks to the high fat and low water content, it holds up beautifully in the freezer. Keep reading for fresh flavor ideas and the pie-making tips our experts swear by. FROM OUR KITCHEN We recently interviewed four pie shop owners to get their go-to pie tools, crust-making techniques, and the flavors they're gravitating toward this season. A few recommended fruit-forward options like cranberry and lemon, which can be a nice change of pace after a big Thanksgiving meal. There are also plenty of ways to explore new flavor combinations. Add nutmeg to a pear filling, or top a pie with cardamom whipped cream. You could even dress up a classic key Lime or a lemon cream pie with candied cranberries. Here are four more ideas that will wake up your palate: Masala Spiced Pear Pie GET THE RECIPE Cranberry Sage Pie GET THE RECIPE Key Lime Meringue Pie GET THE RECIPE Mixed Apple Pie With Hazelnut Crumb Crust and Maple Cream GET THE RECIPE BEYOND RECIPES Pie Service When it comes to serving pie, a pretty stand and server can make all the difference. Consider these pieces for putting your Thanksgiving dessert on display. 1. Insulated Pie Tote 2. Forged Pie Server 3. French Gray Ruffle Cake Stand 4. Fantasia Dessert Forks 5. Nordic Ware Pie Dish Three tips for better crust: Pie crust is often the trickiest part of making a pie, so we asked our experts for their best advice. A few tips came up again and again: Keep your ingredients cold. Starting with cold ingredients prevents butter from melting and makes the dough easier to roll out. Even after your dough is rolled and crimped, place it back in the refrigerator to chill while the oven heats up. Keep the butter in chunks (and don't overmix). It might feel counterintuitive to leave visible pieces of butter in your dough, but that's exactly what you want. As the butter melts in the oven, its water turns to steam, creating tiny air pockets in the crust. Those pockets are what give it that flaky texture. Let the dough rest, and longer than you might think. When flour meets water, its proteins form gluten, which needs time to fully hydrate and relax. Rest your dough for at least four hours, and ideally eight hours or overnight. This will make it easier to roll out and allow it to hold its shape better through assembly and baking. -Food52 Have a question? Visit our Help Page to get in touch. Replies to this email will not be answered. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices and availability are subject to change. Read our Privacy Policy. To update the newsletters you receive, click here. To unsubscribe from our emails, click here. Copyright (C) 2026 Food52, All rights reserved.