Food52
Day 42 after signup
Thanksgiving served stress-free
Menu help is on the way.
Why it works
- Open with a relatable hosting problem, then connect it to a practical method readers can use.
- Organize advice into short, clearly labeled sections so readers can scan for the help they need.
- Keep the recommendations grounded in the editorial advice, making product mentions feel like part of the hosting guidance.
How it is built
- Newsletter introduction
- Editor’s hosting story
- Menu planning advice
- Thanksgiving preparation tips
Email copy
Welcome to Come On Over, Food52's newsletter about hosting life's big and little moments. This week, we’re focused on the biggest meal of the year. Our editor Allie gives us her tips on preparing a Thanksgiving feast like no other. Personally, I hate feeling stressed. (Bombshell, I know.) One of my biggest hosting hurdles has been in that moment just before guests arrive—and feeling utterly behind. The plates aren’t out. Is the turkey done? My mom is here 20 minutes early. Why is there no ice? To prevent this annual falling-to-pieces, I started making “menus”—and not just for food. Spreadsheets can feel like a chore to me, so I make a menu for drinks, food, and even decor. Call it a checklist, fine, but it's an approachable way to organize weeks ahead of time. For decor, I’ll start putting things aside starting now. Designate a corner of a table, or get a box, and start gathering your tablecloth, candlesticks, placemats, napkins, and the like. For drinks, I like to make a specific menu of my offerings—a wine, a light beer, a cocktail or punch—with ingredients. Later, it'll serve double duty as my shopping list. This weekend, I’ll start deciding on my food menu. Caramelized Brussels Sprouts with Pepitas and Pomegranate or Farro Gratin? I’ll list out my snacks, appetizers, sides, mains, and desserts. It’s the best way for me to see if I'm going overboard. (I always am.) I cross things off, then make a second draft that’s more reasonable. Again, list ingredients and use it to shop later. Keep these "menus" handy on Thanksgiving Day and you can actually cross things off as you set the table and put out dishes. If ice is on that list, you’ll know you have it. And if Mom is early, well, she can open the wine. Guest Dishes The last thing you want is three variations of green bean casserole on the table—or none at all. Double check with your guests a week before Thanksgiving to make sure they’re still committed to their dish. Appetizer Smarts Balancing appetizers with a huge feast is a tightrope walk. Instead of offering unlimited cheese and meats, I make a limited amount of composed, small bites. Like my 30 Clove Garlic Dip on crackers. When it all runs out, that’s it until dinner time. Make-Ahead Gravy To ensure the gravy isn’t stressing you out at the last minute, freeze it now. You can either freeze your roux or make the complete gravy and freeze it flat. When needed, break it up and reheat it in a pot. Stir in the drippings after the turkey is out. Steak Knives When push comes to shove, any forks or spoons work at the table, but not those butter knives. Get a set or two of good quality steak knives so guests feel well-equipped to tackle the roast and hearty veg dishes—and they’ll feel a bit pampered, too. A Carving Knife This is really a treat for the chef. Carving the roast is by no means a small task. Make sure you have an eight or 10-inch carving knife or chef's knife for the job. A larger knife will give you more control, and allow for fewer, cleaner cuts. Serving Spoons Truly, you can never have enough serving spoons. Casseroles, salads, roasted sprouts, gratins, sauce—everything needs them. So just when you think you have enough serving spoons, order three more. We've been enjoying this vintage set. Have a question? Visit our Help Page to get in touch. Replies to this email will not be answered. When you choose to purchase our editorial recommendations from the links we provide, we may earn an affiliate commission. Prices and availability are subject to change. Read our Privacy Policy. To update the newsletters you receive, click here. To unsubscribe from our emails, click here.