Eater
Day 32 after signup
The witchy vibes are eternal at these restaurants
Plus, restaurants are dressing up as other restaurants for Halloween
Why it works
- Open with a timely seasonal angle, then connect it to a broader subject that gives the issue more depth.
- Use specific examples and the writer’s perspective to make a roundup feel like an editorial story rather than a list.
- Place related links and newsletter recommendations after the main features so they extend the issue without interrupting its flow.
How it is built
- Date and personal intro
- Witchy restaurant feature
- Halloween pop-up roundup
Email copy
View on web October 27, 2026 Let’s call this one the Halloween special. I’d love to know what food- or restaurant-related looks you’ve got planned for the weekend — is anyone going as a bag of Elizabeth Holmes’ turkey jerky? Bettina Makalintal At these restaurants, it’s witchy vibes all the time I’ve had witchy restaurants on my radar recently, since I read Tierney Plumb of Eater DC’s opening feature of Ellizabetta La Strega, which she describes as a “mystical Italian restaurant.” “La strega,” of course, is the Italian word for witch. Here, chicken milanese is on the menu as “Wiccan chicken.” Cocktails get their names from Jenny Greenteeth, the green-skinned hag of English folklore, and the Socouyant, the shapeshifting, blood-sucking creatures of the Caribbean. It’s not happy hour but “witching hour.” As owner Elli Benchimol told Plumb, the lore goes a little deeper: The restaurant “moves in cycles within cycles: the moon, the season, the mood, the meal, the night,” Benchimol said. Alongside the steakhouse Ox & Olive, with its showstopping centerpiece of drippy tallow candles and a custom deer antler chandelier, it suggests a goth-y restaurant moment across the District, in which the dark, haunted vibe is not simply a factor of Halloween, but ever-present. Steve Parke/Ellizabetta La Strega There are a crop of establishments like this not just in Washington, D.C., but across the country. In Los Angeles, the fantasy cafe The Witch’s Cottage welcomes guests to walk in “as a witch, or a dragon, or just a FedEx worker” without any judgment, according to a Los Angeles Times feature earlier this year. Hecate opened in Boston in 2022, getting its name from the Greek goddess associated with magic and witchcraft and serving occult-inflected drinks in a setting that Nathan Tavares once described for Eater Boston as “underworld-chic: dark and, at first, almost disorienting.” Ultimately, he concluded, the concept was about the ability to immerse oneself in another world, where the expectations of reality didn’t fully apply. I do miss the ambitiously weird and very on-theme Foul Witch in New York City, which closed last year. Described as “spooky Italian,” its menu of testa (pig’s head) and veal tortellini proved that a kitschy concept and serious food could coexist. With magic, some witches can be resurrected. In New Orleans, Tatlo has reopened. Chef Cristina Quackenbush quickly drew attention with her intriguing concept — which she described as a “Filipino witchy absinthe bar and kitchen serving divine food,” and which still bills itself as being “for the bewitched and hex-curious” — when she first opened Tatlo in September 2024. Rising rents led to its quick closure the following summer, but the restaurant recently returned to the same location. (According to the Times-Picayune, Quackenbush was able to negotiate more favorable terms with the restaurant’s landlord; maybe that is its own kind of sorcery.) At Tatlo, each offering on the menu is guided by what a diner might be seeking. The dish of “peanut butter and belly,” Tatlo’s take on Filipino kare kare, is listed as bringing “affluence, strength, and virility,” while the Aunt Nan’s Old Fashioned cocktail made with rice whisky, jackfruit, and bitters promises to offer prosperity. As my former colleague Clair Lorell once explained for Eater NOLA, visits to Tatlo even ended with the option of taking part in a manifestation ritual that involved writing wishes or desires onto bay leaves, then burning them. As Quackenbush told Lorell, the ritual represents embracing a change of mindset. As with the Witch’s Cottage, the idea is ultimately about acceptance: Quackenbush has also described Tatlo as a place where “different practices, beliefs, cultures, and paths can be shared and appreciated without judgment.” What the witchy restaurant asks of its visitors is to believe a little bit — even if only temporarily. My favorite Halloween tradition returns: restaurants dressing up as other