The Marshall Project
Day 21 after signup
The specter of Willie Horton
How criminal justice reform has held its ground against “tough on crime,” even in an election year.
Why it works
- The subject uses a recognizable historical reference to frame a current political story and invite readers in.
- The piece moves from background to present-day examples, then adds research and limitations for a balanced analysis.
- A brief event invitation appears before the main article, while the newsletter's central editorial remains the focus.
How it is built
- Donate link
- Artwork introduction
- Event invitation
- Historical context
Email copy
Donate This week's art is by Frank Blazquez. Full work below. View in browser By Jamiles Lartey Join The Marshall Project for a concert: We hope you’ll join us and Musicambia on October 28 in NYC for Redemption Songs, a one-of-a-kind show that combines live music, storytelling, and journalism to tell the story of mass incarceration, one song at a time. Learn more and get your tickets. Nearly 40 years after his name became synonymous with one of the most consequential political ads in U.S. history, Willie Horton is back on the campaign trail. Not William Horton, mind you, who is incarcerated in Maryland and who never actually went by “Willie.” Rather, it’s the Willie Horton of campaign mythology, a specter that has haunted American politics since the 1988 presidential election, and one that President Donald Trump has summoned in recent weeks, including in a social media post on Monday attacking North Carolina Democratic Senate candidate Roy Cooper. Horton was serving a life sentence for murder in Massachusetts when he was granted a weekend furlough in 1986, a common practice at the time. He fled, and was later convicted of assault, rape, and attempted murder in a 1987 Maryland home invasion. The following year, his case became the centerpiece of a notorious campaign ad attacking Democratic Presidential nominee Michael Dukakis, then governor of Massachusetts, over the state’s furlough program — essentially a warning about the dangers of policies that let people out of prison. Now as the midterm elections approach, Trump and North Carolina Republican Senate candidate Michael Whatley are trying to draw a similar connection regarding Roy Cooper, the former governor of North Carolina, and the killing of Iryna Zarutska, a Ukrainian refugee stabbed to death aboard a Charlotte light-rail train last year. The man accused of killing her, Decarlos Brown Jr., had a criminal history and was free awaiting trial on an unrelated misdemeanor charge. There’s no evidence that Cooper’s policies were responsible for Brown’s release, but Trump has sought to pin the killing on the former governor, calling it a “Willie Horton — modern-day tragedy.” Trump’s retelling has embellished the Horton mythology too. The president has repeatedly claimed that Horton murdered three women after his furlough, a claim for which there is no known evidence. Invoking Willie Horton is a particularly literal example of a broader Republican campaign strategy this election. The Associated Press reported earlier this month that GOP candidates in dozens of races across the country are attacking their Democratic opponents by calling them “soft-on-crime”, reviving exaggerated warnings about defunding the police, and promising more punitive approaches to public safety. Many Democrats have responded in turn by burnishing their own law-enforcement bona fides. In Virginia, for example, House candidate Shannon Taylor aired an ad featuring endorsements from county sheriffs in response to attacks by opponent Rob Wittman that included a website focused on defining her as “soft.” That dynamic — Republicans on the attack and Democrats on the defensive over crime and punishment — seemed to recede somewhat during the bipartisan criminal justice reform movement of the 2010s. Its re-emergence has come alongside a broader political effort to roll back some of those reforms, a recurring theme in this newsletter. That political shift is also visible in the policies being put directly before voters. According to Ballotpedia, all 16 statewide ballot measures concerning criminal sentencing, penalties, and bail since 2022 have sought to make those policies more restrictive. That’s a sharp reversal from 2012 through 2020, when less punitive measures outnumbered tougher ones 11 to five, according to Ballotpedia. But the criminal justice reform movement, it turns out, is hardly dead. In a report released this week, the Vera Institute of Justice identified 425 criminal justice reform and