The Marshall Project
Day 28 after signup
A criminal justice midterms guide
Bolts founder Daniel Nichanian walks us through the races and ballot items he’s watching when it comes to criminal justice on Election Day.
Why it works
- Introduce a guest contributor with relevant credentials before presenting their perspective.
- Set the stakes with a short overview, then organize the analysis into clear issue-based sections.
- Link to deeper reporting where readers may want more detail, rather than trying to explain every race in one email.
How it is built
- Sponsor and header
- Editor and guest introduction
- Election context
- Issue-by-issue analysis
Email copy
Presented by Alfred A. Knopf Donate This week's art is by Frank Blazquez. Full work below. View in browser Edited by Daniel Nichanian Daniel Nichanian founded Bolts Magazine in 2022; it is an independent newsroom that covers local races that don’t always make national headlines but have a huge impact on people’s lives. Think sheriffs, prosecutors, judges and ballot measures that shape everything from criminal sentences to policing technology. He is one of the best people to help make sense of what’s at stake in the midterm elections, so I asked him to take over today’s newsletter. You can subscribe to “From the Local Up,” Bolts’ weekly newsletter, for updates on the politics and elections that shape the justice system. With the midterms just 10 days away, you’re probably closely watching the battle for Congress, and for good reason: Control of the U.S. House and Senate are the biggest ticket items on Nov. 3. But if you’re reading this, chances are you also care about criminal justice and law enforcement, issues largely shaped by down-ballot races all over the country. Some sheriffs connected to far-right organizations are seeking reelection. So are state supreme court justices who have tackled major cases on sentencing and defendants’ rights. In prosecutor races, reform candidates are once again testing whether the legal system can be changed from the inside. And voters will weigh in on some criminal justice policies directly via ballot measures, including deciding whether to restrict pretrial release or require local cooperation with federal immigration authorities. At Bolts, we recently published a cheat sheet to hundreds of local and state elections in the 2026 midterms. And I’ve spent much of the past year tracking the most pivotal contests across the country on criminal justice issues. Here’s what I’m following: Dozens of elections for state supreme courts In 27 states, voters will elect justices to their state supreme courts. These courts matter for civil cases, from redistricting and abortion rights to lawsuits against other state laws or procedures. But they are also the highest local authority in criminal cases. The Michigan Supreme Court, for instance, has issued major rulings recently that have repeatedly restricted life-without-the-possibility-of-parole sentences. Two justices who joined the majority in those rulings, Democrats Megan Cavanagh and Noah Hood, are running for reelection against a pair of Republican challengers. In California, the two justices who are up for reelection took opposing sides in a 2024 ruling that upheld the practice of sentencing young adults to life without parole. Meanwhile, in Oregon, Justice Chris Garrett, who is up for a second term, recently voted with the majority in a ruling that forced the state to dismiss criminal cases if it cannot guarantee timely legal counsel to defendants. And in Washington state, which has been home to several landmark criminal justice decisions in recent years, the majority of the court is on the ballot all at once — the only state where that’s the case. To learn more, read Bolts’ guide to every state supreme court election. Ballot measures on punishment and policing Virginia’s state constitution declares that anyone with a felony conviction loses the right to vote for life. The policy dates back to 1902, when politicians gathered for a constitutional convention aimed at entrenching white supremacy in state politics. More than a century later, that extraordinarily harsh rule may soon be overturned: Virginians are voting on a constitutional amendment in November that would restore the right to vote to anyone who is not presently incarcerated. The Virginia referendum is just one of many ballot measures next month that will affect the shape of policing and incarceration. Coloradans are voting on a measure, sponsored by a conservative organization, that would require local law enforcement to collaborate with federal immigration authorities