Ahrefs Digest

In the last Digest, I shared a post from Marie Haynes who argued that GEO is a distraction. Turns out she wasn’t the only one saying it. 

Kevin Indig also ran an experiment and couldn’t find a reliable link between AI visibility and subsequent branded search or direct traffic. Then, Rand took their studies, made a video on LinkedIn, and boom! It went viral.

That take must have triggered a lot of marketers, because so many of them (besides the 400 comments on Rand’s post) came out to give their take too.

I’ve shared some of them in this week’s Digest.

Tell me: What do you think? Do you agree with Marie and Rand that GEO is a distraction? Or do you heavily disagree? Hit ‘reply’ and let me know! (Don’t worry, this is a safe space.)

Meme of the week

 

—

Quick search marketing news

  • Google is testing a completely revamped performance report section within Google Business Profiles that includes metrics on engagement, reviews, search trends, audience and more. It also includes top recommendations and a more broken-out reviews detail view.

  • Google has launched a new "home" for Google Business Profiles named Google Business Home. It is a beta, but the goal is to bring together a website’s Business Profile, Merchant Center, YouTube, and Ads accounts all in one place.

—

Best of the week

AI Search Is Not a Distraction, It’s a Branding Channel: Mike King isn’t arguing with last week’s numbers. Yes, ChatGPT sends just 0.62% of the traffic Google organic does. But his beef is with the conclusion: You’re not meant to judge AI search via clicks. That’s like judging a Super Bowl ad by its click-through rate and deciding TV is a waste of money.

Dear SEOs, We Must Talk About Marketing: Marketing used to be hard to measure. Then came online analytics. We could finally “see” or approximate what our marketing was doing. But then came the problem: We started to redefine marketing according to what our analytics platforms can measure. This is the classic fallacy most of us fall into: the map is not the territory. This is the exact problem Jono Alderson pointed out last week. Just because the map isn’t measuring properly anymore (aka clicks) doesn’t mean the territory isn’t working. Otherwise, should you cancel your podcast, or your YouTube show, or the LinkedIn thought leadership? People are using ChatGPT and getting influenced by its recommendations, even if it’s not showing up as a referral in GA4.

How People Use ChatGPT (OpenAI Signals): OpenAI just updated its dataset on how people use ChatGPT. The most interesting finding, courtesy of Kevin Indig was “48% of all messages were Google-style questions in September 2026, up from 43% in July 2024. The 48% breaks down into 20% simple searches (facts, products, recipes) and 28% Practical Guidance (how-to, tutoring, health, creative ideas).”

Google AI Mode: All You Need to Know: Whether you see AI search as a distraction or a brand channel, AI Mode isn’t going anywhere. I’ve updated our guide with everything you need to know: how it works, how to track it, and how to optimize for it.

How AI Agents Use Websites, Where They Fail, and What to Fix: MERJ watched AI agents try to complete tasks on websites. A lot of what tripped them up is stuff accessibility already fixes: unlabeled buttons, divs pretending to be buttons, cookie banners covering the page. In one test, an agent asked to save a document clicked “Cancel” first in 25 out of 25 runs. The Cancel thing made me laugh. But it’s also a bit scary, because you’d never know this was happening on your site. Nobody files a support ticket when an agent fails.

—

Latest from our podcast


This week’s podcast guest is Ryan Law, Ahrefs' Director of Content Marketing.

Ryan recently built Conference Spotter, a feed of upcoming UK marketing conferences, in a single day. He used Letaido, Ahrefs' AI agent workspace, and spent less than $500 in tokens.

Ryan takes Tim through his site one feature at a time: the first prompt (a list of events scraped from search queries), the brand-demand charts from Ahrefs keyword data, and the domain the agent bought.

You'll come away knowing which parts an agent now does for you, which parts still need your judgment, and why both people and Google reward a site that shows effort.

Watch the full episode on YouTube.

—

Latest from our YouTube


How I Make $32M A Year Dominating This SEO Niche

His agency does $32M a year dominating personal injury SEO, not competing - here is the playbook Chris Dreyer used to own his niche and what it took to get there.

See you next week,
Si Quan

P.S. Liked this week’s Digest? Forward it to a friend or tell them to subscribe here.

Honest verdict on this one?

🔥  Banger 🙂  Fine 😴  Snooze