Nieman Lab
The Weekly Wrap: October 23, 2026

“Broad enough to drive a truck through”

Measuring impact is hard for news organizations. But every once in awhile, change caused by reporting is noticeable and swift, and here at Nieman Lab that’s been the case with Hanaa’ and Andrew’s recent reporting on Meta changing its terms of service for business accounts on October 30. Andrew and Hanaa’ spoke with legal experts who told them that, as written, the new terms could be used to argue that Meta can scrape content from news sites and use that content to train the company’s AI products.

The blowback was almost immediate. While Meta revised the terms, they still grant broad scraping permissions (“broad enough to drive a truck through,” as James Grimmelmann, a professor of digital and information law at Cornell Law School, put it). Publishers and media associations in the U.S. and abroad have expressed concern, filed complaints, and called for government action. On Thursday, Meta announced it would delay the implementation of the new terms until November 20.

See these stories, and everything else we published this week, below. And at the bottom of the email, you’ll find the best of what we read around the internet this week — if you’re looking to catch up on a few journalism stories over the weekend, try these.

— Laura Hazard Owen

Meta delays rollout of terms that would allow broad scraping of news sites. Legal experts are still skeptical.

Meta’s new commercial terms will go into effect three weeks later than initially planned. By Hanaa' Tameez.

The Ringer bets on Substack’s network over its own website

Once synonymous with independent writers, Substack is increasingly home to established publishers. By Sarah Scire.

The Wall Street Journal’s new AI tool, “Doppler,” forecasts the issues that will shape the midterm elections

Ahead of Election Day, the tool has ingested 25 million TikTok videos and 500,000 podcasts to gain new insight into U.S. voters. By Andrew Deck.

When hackers become sources: Inside the new craft of reporting on hacked data

“You’ve definitely seen the maturity of some hackers in how they approach the media. It’s not just about posting things to Twitter like it might have been before.” By Philip Di Salvo.
Publishers pressure Meta to nix new terms that would let the company scrape their websites
In the AI age, publishers who understand what readers want will do best, a new report argues
U.K. politicians and German publishers call on regulators to pause Meta’s new terms before October 30 deadline
Two out of five Americans regularly get their news on Facebook
What we’re reading
⁂

The portion of chatbots’ answers to election-related questions that contained at least one factual inaccuracy, according to a forthcoming report from the startup Forum AI. For instance, “when Forum’s researchers asked one widely used model when they needed to request a mail-in ballot to vote in the midterms in Pennsylvania, the chatbot said November 3. The actual deadline is a week earlier.” (The Atlantic / Will Oremus)

⁂
The New York Times / Ruth Graham
Christianity Today is in turmoil; about half of its 79 staffers have left over the last 14 months →

“Bonnie Kristian, Christianity Today’s deputy editor until last week, described its new leaders as being driven ‘by fear, by the kind of anxiety about reputational and financial loss that makes bold, interesting, principled journalism very difficult.'”

Employees who have left Christianity Today in recent months fear those in charge are “abandoning the publication’s longtime commitment to independent journalism, a record that includes investigating accounts of misconduct by high-profile evangelicals.”

CNN / T.M. Brown
The anti-AI writing police are everywhere. What are they looking for? →

“Pangram isn’t able to tell users the truth about someone’s writing, but it is able to introduce something much more complicated: doubt…once an accusation is made, there’s no consensus about what evidence would be sufficient to clear an author’s name.”

The New York Times / Erik Wemple
Alaska’s journalists join forces to cover the midterms →

“Veteran journalists in the state have come to view competing outlets working on the same story as wasteful duplication. ‘There are so many stories in Alaska and so much here that goes uncovered, and there is absolutely no good reason why anyone should be competing at this point,’ said Nathaniel Herz, executive editor of The Anchorage Press, a monthly newspaper. ‘Resources now are such that it really does cry out for better cooperation.'”

Book Gossip / Jasmine Vojdani
Are writers of color facing disproportionate scrutiny right now? →

“I don’t take lightly what it means to suggest that a professional writer’s work could be AI generated,” [The Atlantic’s Vauhini Vara] said. “But the incursion of corporate AI into cultural and artistic production is a matter of enormous public interest, and the Caine Prize is one of the most high-profile and prestigious literary prizes in the world. If Pangram interprets a prizewinning story as almost 100 percent AI — and all previous 25 winners of the prize as 100 percent human — it is in the public interest to raise the possibility that the Pangram analysis is correct.”

Wired / Adam Rogers
How Elizabeth Holmes tricked Wired — and everyone else →

“If Theranos’ technology didn’t quite work yet, well, that’s a core tenet of Silicon Valley: Fake it till you make it.

And for a long time, Wired helped. The magazine touted big ideas, and sometimes those ideas turned out to be dumb. Sometimes we were too early; sometimes we were wrong. Pitch meetings for stories big and small were a bit of a Thunderdome, actually. Eventually we developed some heuristics to encode skepticism in the process.”

Media Nation / Dan Kennedy
Boston.com shifts to mostly paid as Globe Media CEO Linda Henry says free news no longer works →

“Today, after experimenting with a soft paywall for the past year, Boston.com will be converting to a mostly paid outlet. The change is indicative of how digital advertising has lost much of its value and of how the rise of AI search has deprived news organizations of click-throughs.”

★ Nieman Reports / Vidya Krishnan
India targets journalists in crackdown on growing protest movement →

“If the idea is to intimidate protesters into not protesting, the attacks on reporters — rough handling, groping, detention — is a corollary. Both the government and Delhi Police want to work in the shadows, and here, the attack on freelancers and alternative media is inevitable. They are the only ones doing any meaningful work on the ground.”

Nonce: e608f3d0bdba61b254ceafb3d18a54de