Authenticity is a big buzz word right now, but one that actually deserves the brouhaha. When we’re bombarded with AI-generated food content, a seemingly endless parade of grifters (have you seen You Can See Everything yet?), and a never-ending assault of head-scratching celebrity brand collaborations, it seems like an increasingly distant desire; the truth has perhaps never been such a scarce commodity.
It’s also an increasingly slippery component of online restaurant reviews. More and more often, there’s something off about reviews on Yelp and Google. I can see them now: “This was such a memorable experience,” the faux post will usually read, “Wife and I came on our anniversary. Steak cooked to perfection. Service attentive. Beautiful ambiance. Can’t wait to return.” (A telltale sign will always be some version of “the wife loves it,” whether you’re deciding where to make a dinner reservation or online shopping for sex toys.)
The practice of restaurants gamifying their reviews, either through incentivized coverage or fake customer reviews, is not new. But the long-tail data about how being exposed for fakes impacts their businesses is finally starting to unfold. A recently published working paper on the consequences for restaurants that get caught and penalized for publishing fake reviews on Yelp reveals that since 2023 more than 4,900 businesses have been flagged with Yelp’s “Consumer Alert” banner, which is stamped across the business’s Yelp page for 90 days as a penalty for fake reviews. But the long-term impacts of that digital pillory extend far beyond that duration. Even after 18 months, many restaurants couldn’t bounce back.
There was a time when an above-4.5-star rating was enough to lock me into making a reservation at a new restaurant, long before AI-generated, anthropomorphic-fruit love triangles were popping up on my TikTok feed. Now, the digital aspects of a restaurant I want to try don’t even feel like they need to be outstanding — they just feel like they have to be real.
Read more about what happens when restaurants are exposed for faking it here.