Capitalism is more than a legal regime |
By E. Ahmet Tonak “Capitalism is a legal regime, not just an economic system as conventional wisdom has it.” With this opening sentence, Katharina Pistor takes the argument of her previous book, The Code of Capital, a step further. There she showed how lawyers turn assets into capital through property, contract, collateral, trust, corporate, and bankruptcy law. Her new book extends the argument to capitalism as a whole. If law so thoroughly constitutes capitalism, she asks, why is it “so resistant to legal governance”? And how might we transform it? Pistor has much to say about the legal powers of capital, and her account deserves serious attention. Yet I find two fundamental problems with her argument. Although she insists that capitalism is legal to the core, she has remarkably little to say about the wage relation and the extraction of surplus labor in the production process. Without these, we can understand neither capitalist production nor its capacity to reproduce itself. This omission carries over into her proposals for transforming capitalism. Her project of democratizing private law leaves the basic relations of production intact. The result is a reform program that may constrain some of capital’s powers but offers little prospect of overcoming capitalist exploitation. The second, related problem concerns the economic foundations of her argument. Pistor describes her approach as “imbued with a strong dose of political economy.” Yet she makes claims about the redistributive achievements of the welfare state and the sources of capitalist profit without engaging with a substantial body of Marxian theoretical and empirical research that bears directly on both questions. |