Hi there, and welcome back to another edition of On Background, my weekly media newsletter. I am back in New York after spending my last week in Orlando, where I interviewed the AI-generated actress Tilly Norwood. For anyone wondering what that looks like in practice, ADWEEK published a fun social video this morning that captures both the setup and some of my thoughts on the experience. This week, we are publishing a story I have been working on for quite some time: a look into some of the advertising challenges facing Condé Nast, which is on pace to fall around $40 million short of its second-half revenue goals, according to interviews and documents I obtained. The shortfall comes at a particularly challenging time for the publisher, whose chief executive left the company just weeks ago—part of a larger executive exodus that has exacerbated the situation. Below that, check out my interview with social media maven Rachel Karten, creator of the Link in Bio Substack and former member of the famed Bon Appetit Test Kitchen. I had called Karten to get her perspective on a new social format blossoming across the People Inc. portfolio, which you can read about here. But as fate would have it, Instagram released a slew of potentially paradigm-shifting features on the same day we talked, which we naturally discussed. That conversation is below. I also rounded up a few of the most interesting happenings from across the media industry this week, including some highlights from a burgeoning crop of news creators, an inexplicable uptick in CPG coverage, and Reddit’s efforts to push its users onto its mobile app. As always, I included a few of my favorite media reporting stories of the week at the bottom of the newsletter, this week featuring stories from The New York Times, Vanity Fair, and Variety. Replies to this email go straight to my inbox, so feel free to reach out with tips, pitches, and feedback. You can reach me at mark.stenberg@adweek.com or on Signal at 210-705-3284. If you are not yet subscribed to On Background, you can click here to do so for free. |
|
|
If you were forwarded this newsletter, you can sign up here. |
|
|
Morse’s Coda: Last November, I sat down with Andrew Morse, then the CEO of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, as he walked me through his ambitious plan, financed with a $100 million war chest, to turn the publisher into The New York Times of the South. But a few months later, in May, he left the outlet, citing the strain of an interstate commute, among other factors. On Wednesday, Morse revealed his next venture: Phareo, a platform that “helps creators find the audiences they deserve.” Although details around its specific aim are scant, the focus of the startup suggests that Morse came to understand, perhaps even while at the AJC, that creators, rather than legacy news outlets, are the future of the space. The bet is an informed one, but Phareo enters a densely populated creator ecosystem, so it will be interesting to see how it hopes to stand out. CPG Activity: The snack aisle is buzzing. Earlier this month, I reported that Morning Brew had acquired Express Checkout, a creator-led outlet reporting on the CPG space. Then last week, Feed Me reported that Taste had launched Eye Level, its second podcast, to cover the packaged food industry. And today, Inc. launched Packaged Goods, a CPG newsletter on beehiiv that will publish three times a week. Personally, I see no obvious explanation for the trend. If anything, with the rise of GLP-1s, analysts have spent most of the last year forecasting declines in the snack space. Perhaps that same existential threat has spurred a wave of innovation in the industry, prompting an uptick in interest? My personal theory is that, as business-to-business media remains viable while consumer media crumbles, enterprise reporting that also appeals to a broad consumer base—like snack trends, movie sales, the business of sports, etc.—could prove a durable blend of the two categories. Podletters: Last week, I reported that Substack was piloting a program that would enable its podcasters to more easily monetize their shows with programmatic advertising. On Tuesday, beehiiv announced the exact same functionality. That both platforms—previously newsletter operations that now focus on holistic creator monetization—are incentivizing their users to make and monetize podcasts is instructive. It increasingly appears that no newsletter is complete without a podcast, and vice versa: On Wednesday, in fact, Vox Media podcast Pivot announced its plan to launch a Pivot newsletter on Nov. 2, called Pivot Post. I have written this before, but the products once seen as add-ons to existing media businesses—newsletters, podcasts, events in some instances—are now considered Step 1 in launching a new media venture. App Attack: The decline of the open web continues to push publishers to stand up mobile apps. Vox launched its first mobile app on Wednesday, while The Atlantic announced a slew of updates to its offering on Tuesday. Even more interesting: Reddit itself is now pushing users to move off the web and download its app, according to new data from market intelligence firm Sensor Tower. In a report released Wednesday, the firm found that downloads of the Reddit mobile app grew six percentage points in the third quarter, the highest growth of any social media platform in the last year. The trend is no accident: Reddit is actively restricting its mobile web experience, prompting users to download the app to access content, per Sensor Tower. Nearly one-third (32%) of Reddit iOs reviews mentioned being prompted to use the app, up from 2% in the same quarter a year ago.
|
|
|
Rachel Karten is the creator of Link in Bio, a Substack newsletter about social media strategy for brands and publishers with over 120,000 subscribers. Before she went independent, Karten was also a member of the social media team behind the famous Bon Appétit Test Kitchen. I had called Karten to get her perspective on the episodic social video format that People Inc. has rolled out across a handful of its brands, a story you can read here. But on Monday, when we spoke, Instagram had just announced that it was unveiling a series of new features, including a hub for long-form video and series, as well as new ways to discover longer videos and livestreams in Reels. In our conversation, I asked Karten what she thought about the new formats, why serialized video works so well on the platform, and what publishers can learn from InStyle. This interview has been edited. Mark Stenberg: What did Instagram announce, and what does it add up to? Rachel Karten: The big announcement is the test of a long-form hub on profiles. You might be on your Explore page, click a video, and find that it’s 12 minutes long. Instagram may also start recommending videos over 3 minutes, which used to be the limit. Until now, a 3-minute Reel was as deep as you could go with your favorite creator. Instagram wants Reels to be a funnel, so you go down a rabbit hole and maybe watch 90 minutes from that creator. Mark: Where do series, like InStyle’s The Intern, fit into that? Rachel: Instagram also announced a dedicated hub for series. So now when you’re served Episode 27 of a series on Reels, there will be UI in the tab that lets you click through and watch every episode. Mark: Publishers like People Inc are beginning to lean into this. What makes that work? Rachel: Publishers usually tack themselves onto cultural events, which makes them somewhat interchangeable. With The Intern, InStyle is creating its own IP. You’re learning about InStyle, but you’re also returning to watch again and again. Plus that familiarity can help with engagement: When you know the characters, you’re more likely to stop scrolling. Mark: What does this say about where Instagram is heading? Rachel: I look at the signals these announcements send, and they say Instagram is more of an entertainment platform than a community platform. I watch YouTube on my TV, so I think Instagram on TV is possible. Mark: What challenges does this format present for brands? Rachel: The way social is moving requires brands to narrow their focus. I’m curious what would happen if InStyle launched an account just for The Intern and kept its main account about its own content. Away, the luggage company, did something like this with a separate account, and it thrived. And if you’re putting employees into serialized social video, especially sponsored episodes, I recommend talent contracts. |
|
|
THE LEDE: Condé Nast’s Q4 Ad Business Forecast to Fall $35 Million Short As the publisher searches for a new CEO, insiders blame an exodus of senior sales talent and a lack of clear commercial strategy |
|
|
Condé Nast is forecasting roughly $130 million in U.S. advertising bookings for the fourth quarter, more than $35 million below its internal goal, according to internal figures viewed by ADWEEK and a person familiar with its finances. The shortfall follows a third quarter in which the publisher behind Vogue, GQ, and The New Yorker booked nearly $110 million in U.S. advertising revenue, about $6 million below its internal Q3 goal, according to the figures, but up about 5% year-over-year. Together, the two quarters leave the company more than $40 million behind its advertising targets for the second half of the year. A spokesperson for Condé Nast disputed these figures. “While we do not disclose detailed financial information as a privately held company, the figures cited and the resulting percentage variance are materially inaccurate,” said Condé Nast chief corporate affairs and communications officer Danielle Carrig. “U.S. advertising revenue surpassed our targets in the first half. We are projecting U.S. advertising revenue to be very close to target for the full year.” The second-half shortfalls do not necessarily mean that the company generated less revenue than it has in years past. However, the miss is particularly painful given that the fourth quarter is the most critical period for media companies, as advertisers typically allocate a high portion of their annual ad spend to the fourth quarter to capture holiday shopping. The deficit arrives at a delicate moment for the publisher. In September, chief executive Roger Lynch announced he was leaving after seven-and-a-half years to become CEO of Mattel. Board member Mike Perlis is serving as interim chief executive while the company searches for a permanent replacement. It also follows a year of high-profile departures from the revenue organization, many of them executives who reported to chief revenue officer Elizabeth Herbst-Brady. To report this story, ADWEEK reviewed a number of internal documents, as well as spoke with four people familiar with the Condé Nast business, all of whom requested anonymity to discuss sensitive matters. Their accounts describe a company facing the same declines in search traffic battering every publisher with a web presence, but one whose revenue strategy, they said, has been waylaid by a swath of executive departures and unrealistic expectations. A $35 million hole At Condé Nast, a budgeting shortfall of that size is unusual by historical standards, according to a person familiar with the business, particularly since the fourth-quarter budget was built largely off the prior year’s results. “How were your expectations so off?” they said. “Either you mismanaged the business or can’t forecast. Both bad.” The second half had looked weak for months, according to two people familiar with the business. Revenue leaders also set targets they knew were unrealistic to accommodate Anna Wintour, Condé’s global chief content officer, according to one of the people. When publishers miss annual budgets, they can resort to layoffs to account for the difference. In recent years, Condé Nast has implemented staff reductions in November 2023, December 2024, and November 2025. Vogue World, the experiential spectacle that moves to a new city each year, is also expected to come in well below last year. The 2025 Hollywood edition brought in just under $30 million, according to a person familiar with the event. This year’s edition, which took place last month in Milan, was pacing to bring in less than $20 million, according to people familiar with the business. Some of that decline is about geography, said two people familiar with the strategy, since U.S. advertisers are reluctant to sponsor an event held abroad. Condé Nast’s Carrig disputed that figure. “Vogue World Milan brought in $26 million,” she said, “and Vogue donated a record $3 million to the redevelopment of the Quarto Oggiaro Library as part of the event.” A soft tentpole matters well beyond the event itself, according to one person familiar with the business, because flagship events help draw advertisers into larger media buys. “You use the big-ticket events to drive the overall deals,” they said. “If you don’t have a hook, people aren’t coming to buy your media inventory.” The challenges have been exacerbated by several key departures. In May, Doug Grinspan, chief business officer for U.S. sales and global key accounts at Condé Nast, left the company. Former employees described his exit as a pivotal loss for Condé Nast, as Grinspan had managed relationships with several of its top advertisers. Since then, head of marketing Sophia Zhang has also left the company after less than a year. Grinspan and Zhang did not respond to a request for comment. The turnover in sales leadership has compounded the challenges facing the publisher, leaving it without a clear commercial strategy, according to four people familiar with the situation. In a wry nod to this lack of direction, at a meeting this spring Lynch presented the company strategy as a series of blank slides, according to a person familiar with the presentation. “Everyone who is a leader is gone,” said a person familiar with the strategy. “And everyone who is a leader by title right now is just counting down till their severance comes up.” |
|
|
"Those that exist, exist because of the beneficence of wealthy patrons." |
— Former Life magazine editor Daniel Okrent, on many legacy publishers’ commercial model READ MORE |
|
|
"We think of ourselves as journalists, but creators too, doing credible investigative work." |
— Newsgirls creators Wren Woodson and Mabel Kabani, on their new-age news outlet READ MORE |
|
|
"On the surface, it looks effortless. But, obviously, the duck is treading underwater while trying to look calm on top." |
— Local News International creator Dave Jorgenson, on expanding from short-form into long-form video reporting READ MORE |
|
|
"These guys have millions of followers in a demographic that I’ve been chasing for decades." |
— Former 60 Minutes executive producer Bill Owens, on why he joined the YouTube news publisher Newpress READ MORE |
|
|
Mark Stenberg is Adweek's senior media reporter covering the business of digital and print media and publishers, including their advertising, marketing and editorial strategies. Before joining Adweek Mark was a reporter for Business Insider. | |
|
|
|