Rand Fishkin just shared three studies suggesting that AI visibility might be a scam. The numbers certainly raised some eyebrows: | One study found that ChatGPT drives just 0.62% of website traffic Another found that organic search drives 39 times more traffic than AI assistants And a third couldn't find a clear connection between AI visibility and increases in branded searches or direct traffic
| However, these studies are missing something huge: they're measuring website traffic, not how people actually discover businesses through AI. | I have a perfect example from Whitespark: | We ask new customers of our Local Ranking Grid software how they heard about us. Guess what their number one answer is? | ChatGPT! | | Rand doesn’t think you can trust self-reported data, and he makes some good points, but for it to be our number one mentioned source sure seems telling to me. | So, I definitely think that optimizing for AI visibility is worth it. And if you want AI to recommend your business, build a brand that people recommend. | Claire and I talk about this in the new episode of the Whitespark Local Update podcast, and more: | AI Picks the Shortlist: Are You Even Showing Up Locally? (Krystal Taing) Google Business Profiles Verification With Government ID (Barry Schwartz) Google Business Profiles Review Appeals Are Delayed Again (Barry Schwartz) Can You Change The Order of Google Business Profile Photos? (Miriam Ellis) The Local Customer Journey: What AI Has and Hasn't Changed (Duda webinar)
| Watch the episode here 👇️ |  | Is AI Visibility Worth the Hype or Just a Scam? | E53 The Whitespark Local Update |
|
| 🎧 Or if you prefer listening, find it on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. | | Watch by topic:
00:00 Intro 00:27 Can You Change The Order of Google Business Profile Photos? 03:58 AI Picks the Shortlist: Are You Even Showing Up Locally? 08:27 The Local Customer Journey: What AI Has and Hasn't Changed 12:03 Whitespark Live Webinar 12:10 Google Business Profiles Verification With Government ID 15:12 Is AI Visibility a Scam? 19:10 Google Business Profiles Review Appeals Are Delayed Again 22:44 The end! | |  | Don't miss a thing Monitor your ranking changes over time with ultimate clarity. Side-by-side comparisons let you monitor changes point by point, while aggregated scan graphics and metrics let you track major changes at a glance. |
|
|
| | Darren | | P.S. Whitespark can help you ⬇️
😍 Visualize your local search performance on the most beautiful ranking grids
🚨 Get notified when Google updates your GBP and reject unwanted changes
🚀 Increase your local rankings and conversions
📈 Track rankings across different zip/post-codes
⭐️ Get more reviews
🧹 Clean up and build citations
🔍 Find citation opportunities | ✍️ Learn local SEO for free |
|