In an outlier to the big-picture data, my upbringing in the late 1990s to early 2010s was full of dinner parties, both in my home and the homes of my parents’ friends. My mom prided herself in hosting to the point that helping her pull out the chafing dishes (yes, multiple) to have people over was just the typical run-of-show, scheduled sometime between her vacuuming and me cleaning the bathroom. Yet here I am, raised on Martha Stewart Living and inundated with TikTok tablescaping influencers, texting my friends to schedule hangouts in which we almost always just go out to dinner. I’m much more likely to receive an invite to catch up over a dinner out than at a friend’s. (Still, I will admit: There are few things greater than gossiping with a friend over a dinner out.)
A restaurant experience, even at the most casual of spots, is inherently structured and predictable. You show up at the restaurant at an agreed-upon time on an agreed-upon date; perhaps there was even a calendar invite. The meal is made in a specific order on a time scale that generally doesn’t deviate too much from your expectations, and you can count on spending about 90 minutes there before the restaurant starts to shoo you out. People tend to act a certain way at a restaurant, too: generally aware of the way they’re perceived publicly, hewing to the conversation roadmap of the “catch-up.”
In this way, the default of dining out with friends could be another example of the overstructuring and odd formality of many adult friendships now, in which spontaneity and casualness are fleeting. The death of the “casual hang” has been much lamented across social media. “Catch-up culture is killing friendship,” argued a popular essay on a Substack publication called I Remember, citing a term coined by author Michelle Elman.
The argument against “catch-up culture” is that intermittent dinner dates, in which we primarily account what has happened since the last one, do not really constitute experiencing life together. The latter, according to this argument, is built through the intimacy and casualness of experiences like grocery shopping together, or eating snacks on the couch together while watching TV. This has led to what others have dubbed “the friendship depth gap,” in which we increasingly struggle to “let the people in our lives truly know us.” We forget that hosting does not have to mean a big dinner party or a picturesque spread. It can mean a meal that’s humble and perfunctory, in the theoretically lower-stakes setting of home.
I say “theoretically” because ultimately, for me, my failure to host is not about the big-picture factors that Thompson highlights (feeling overworked or stressed from parenting, for example), but about the feeling of being somehow too-seen in my own space and therefore known in ways I don’t want to be known. I worry that I’m actually a bad cook, or that I’ll be judged for the cords I’ve struggled to wrangle, or that my standards for a tidy home are below someone else’s — even though on the occasions that I’ve clocked these things in other people’s homes, I’ve mostly just been thankful they invited me over at all.
How close can you really be to a friend if you won’t show them your weird imperfections, the version of you that is the clearest when you’re in the comfort of your own home and not trying to impress your server with how socially gracious and easygoing you are as a diner? I’ll probably never stop dining out, but for the sake of my friendships, maybe it’s time to send a few “want to come over for dinner?” texts.