His example joins a handful of similar anecdotes, seemingly all from the tech-founder-adjacent class. (Two days later, Bahr-de Stefano announced that Resy had reinstated his account, on the grounds that he would never misuse the platform that way again, and that if he did, the company, which is owned by American Express, could cancel not only his Resy account but also any associated AmEx cards. He seems repentant.)
But this phenomenon will likely only continue, at least until the reservations platforms really push back. With the launch of Meta’s Muse earlier this month, personal AI agents — a category that includes Instinct, along with competitor OpenClaw — are evolving at lightning speed. Just as Temu promised to let anyone “shop like a billionaire,” as its tagline goes, these personal agents are now effectively democratizing the experience of having a personal assistant, checking account balance be damned. According to Meta, Muse can send your emails, make your plans, book your travel, sell your car, and beyond. To that end, Zoë Schiffer described reservation-booking as “a gateway drug for many agent-curious people” in a recent Wired piece about her experience with Instinct. (She noted, citing a recent 404 Media report, that some of these uses attributed to Muse are really just the work of human beings in call centers, however.)
The argument for some users seems to be that if the playing field is already uneven thanks to bots, these different bots might offer people a fighting chance. The rise of the new interfaces is an interesting twist, given that OpenAI also has relatively recent partnerships with Resy, OpenTable, and Yelp that allow diners to make bookings directly through ChatGPT.
While some people like Schiffer have found themselves pleasantly surprised by the merits of Instinct, these interfaces warrant some skepticism. In a new appearance on the podcast Invest Like the Best, Instinct’s 23-year-old CEO Noah Shinn explains his vision for how his platform might change restaurants. To date, he says, reservations have been first come, first served, regardless of why people might want to dine there. AI agents, he explains, can make the case to restaurants that certain diners want to visit for special events. “And the restaurant, too, can say, Let’s actually prioritize birthdays or major decade birthdays or major anniversaries or these certain people, I don’t know, whatever it might be,” Shinn explains. As with many new tech products, it’s one of those ideas that sounds good to CEOs, but starts to fall apart when you consider things like 1) everyone’s agent could just lie, falsely driving up the competition, and 2) restaurants rely on diners going often, not only on special occasions.
A new startup called Spot is now taking aim at the increasingly messy reservations ecosystem. As Alex Konrad, who tried Spot, wrote in his Substack publication Upstarts, a small number of people who have been invited via word of mouth “pay $15 or $50 per month for the privilege of Spot managing booking searches for a selection of restaurants across specific dates, flagging any openings at your favorites across any date, and providing access to more tables across a weekly Sunday drop.” This allowed Konrad to get reservations at NYC restaurants like Ambassadors Clubhouse, which, as of May, boasted a waitlist of over 12,000 people a night; Bistrot Ha; and Le Veau d’Or. “I wasn’t suddenly well-connected,” Konrad wrote on X.
How exactly Spot works is unclear — the startup is still in stealth mode — though from his interview with founder Brian Wagner, Konrad described it as “leveraging technology without the kind of ‘brute force, sledgehammer’ approach that leads to bans” (i.e., presumably not scoping out Resy every 0.4 seconds). As Wagner told Konrad: “It shouldn’t only be people who know how to code, or who pay for ChatGPT Pro, who can get all the tables in New York… We want people who deserve them to be able to get them: the people who most want to eat at those restaurants.”
As much as this relies on the language of democratization, it feels like these tools may also drive us deeper into exclusivity around dining. Spot offers a way for people with means and connections to pay to have a better experience with an app that anyone can use (i.e., Resy), but that has already been meaningfully made worse by bots, scalpers, and personal AI agents. I know that I’ve invoked the phrase “enshittification” in this newsletter before (yes, while talking about reservations), but there feels no better word for it.
Ben Leventhal, co-founder of Resy (and of Eater), wrote a thread on X responding to Instinct and its competitors. His conclusion: “We are going to see a new layer of services develop on top of platforms like Resy, no question. Consumers will benefit big time. But that layer has to be built legitimately and securely and that is precisely what should happen next.” Until then, though, the reservations space might be in for some growing pains.